The Elephant in the Room: The Men We Don’t Become (Part 1)

What a group of rogue elephants can teach us about fatherlessness, mentorship, and healing

We’re living in a generation of unmentored men—untethered, uninitiated, and often unaware of what’s missing.

Too many boys are growing up without the steadying presence of older men—without fathers, uncles, coaches, or mentors to model strength with restraint.

The consequences are showing up everywhere: in schools, in mental health stats, in violence—and yes, even in dating. Women are asking, “Where are the men?” This series starts at the source: not with the men we wish existed, but with the boys who never had the chance to become them.

The Rogue Elephants of Pilanesberg

In the mid-1990s, rangers in South Africa’s Pilanesberg National Park discovered something disturbing. Rhinos were being mysteriously killed—not by poachers, but by teenage elephants.

These elephants were orphans—relocated from another reserve where their parents had been culled. Raised without older male role models, these young bulls became chaotic and aggressive—forming roaming gangs and attacking animals, seemingly for sport.

No one saw it coming. After all, elephants are highly intelligent, social, emotionally attuned creatures. However without the stabilizing presence of adult males, their social order collapsed. These young elephants had no one to guide them, check their behavior, or model maturity. And so chaos unfolded.

Eventually, park officials brought in a few fully grown adult bull elephants. The change was almost immediate. The rogue behavior stopped. The violence dropped off. Interestingly, the older males didn’t fight the younger ones—they simply showed up. And in doing so, they tamed the wildness.

The Crisis of Fatherlessness

So what does this have to do with humans? Everything.

We’re living in a time where nearly 1 in 4 children in the U.S. grow up without a father in the home. And even when dads are physically present, many are emotionally absent, overwhelmed, or unsure how to lead.

Studies show that boys without strong male mentorship are more likely to struggle with:

• Anger and behavioral issues

• Depression, anxiety, and panic attacks

• Poor academic performance

• Substance use

• Difficulty forming healthy relationships

• Suicide

It’s not just about having a man in the house—it’s about what kind of man that boy sees. Boys need to witness emotional regulation, integrity, responsibility, and restraint. Without that, they either act out—or shut down. Often both.

Why This Matters in the Therapy Room

As a trauma-informed therapist, I see a version of this all the time. Men in their 20s, 30s, 40s (and beyond) carrying invisible scars from a lack of guidance. Some are angry. Some are lost. Some over-function to hide the void; others collapse under it.

What they weren’t told—or shown—was how to be strong and emotionally honest. How to be brave and vulnerable. Assertive without aggression.

And so, like those young elephants, they push against boundaries, hurt others (or themselves), or retreat into isolation. And then they show up to therapy saying things like:

“Why do I keep sabotaging my relationships?”

Or, as one client put it perfectly: “People keep telling me to ‘just be myself.’ Well, who the f** is that?”*

Often, the answer lies further back than they realize.

Trauma Isn’t Just What Happened—It’s What Didn’t Happen

You don’t have to be physically harmed to carry trauma. Sometimes, the deepest wounds come from what was missing: The steady hand. The calm voice.

The Strong

presence that said, “I’ve been there. You’ll get through this.”

When boys grow up without grounded, emotionally attuned male role models, they often internalize confusion—or shame—about masculinity itself. They’re told to “man up,” but also “don’t be toxic.” Be strong—but also soft. Be a leader—but never overstep. Be vulnerable—but don’t fall apart.

No wonder so many are confused.

Just like those elephants, we’re wired to learn by modeling. You can’t YouTube manhood. You have to witness it. Feel it. Absorb it.

The Invitation

This isn’t about blame—it’s about awareness. The world doesn’t need “better men” because men are bad. It needs more initiated men—men who are willing to become the mentors, brothers, fathers, and guides.

In the absence of this, good therapy can help.

Not by handing you a script, or telling you to “act like a man,” but by offering something many never received: Containment. Structure. Presence. The same things that calmed those wild elephants.

You don’t need to be fixed. You need space to recover, reveal, and reconnect with who you really are—not who you had to become to survive.

In the next post, we’ll explore how this lack of mentorship is playing out in modern relationships—and why so many people are still asking:

 “Where are all the good men?”